We Understand
You want it to feel special — not like everyone else's.
Finding something truly beautiful, personal, and worth every penny shouldn't be this hard. Generic store options fall flat. DIY takes time you don't have. And most custom bakers make ordering feel complicated. You deserve something that makes people stop and say "Where did you get these?"
-MEET YOUR BAKER
Hi, I'm Tiffany - and I get it. Every detail matters.
"I started Coastal Cookie Co. because I believe every celebration deserves something beautiful — and personal."
Based in charming Lewes, Delaware, I hand-craft every single cookie from scratch — from concept to royal icing detail. I've created hundreds of custom sets for moms, gift-givers, event planners, and businesses across the coast. When you order with me, you're not filling out a form and hoping for the best. You're working with someone who actually cares that your occasion is remembered.
300+ 100% 5
Orders Handmade Repeat
Made Customers
SIMPLE AS 1, 2, 3
Ordering is easy.
Here's exactly what happens when you place an order with us.
Choose
Your
Design
1
We Bake
With
Love
2
Pick Up
&
Celebrate!
3
Browse seasonal pre-sales or submit a custom order request with your theme, colors, and occasion.
Every cookie is hand-iced to order — made fresh and packaged beautifully, ready for pickup.
Collect your cookies in Lewes, DE and show up to your occasion with something truly stunning.
Ready to get started?
📍 Pickup in Lewes, Delaware. Orders close 2 weeks before pickup
